Individual Throttle
Bodies - Part 2
Overview
Fitting
Issues
Tuning
Overview
As you saw in
Part 1 there are a lot of other components to a working ITB
system than just the throttle bodies. Fortunately I had a spare
lower intake manifold to test how everything would fit together
on the bench before final fitting on my car. However many of the
smaller components have changed between initial conception and
what's now running, such as the vacuum collector for the MAP
sensor. I also faced many and
varied problems which challenged my own understanding of intake
systems (which is fairly general) and which also tested my
troubleshooting skills (which are pretty good). Like any new
modification it helps if you know what you should get as an end
result and most of my time was wasted try to solve "problems"
which were just quirks of ITB's... but more on those later.
Fitting
Fitment was actually very straight forward,
and as most things are with Soarers you just follow your nose
and you can't go too wrong. From the time I parked my car until
I first turned the key was 2 days at a leisurely pace BUT it was
another 3 months of one or both days on the weekend working out
the details until I had the car on the road then another month
of fine tuning.
Stripping down the stock intake went
roughly as follows:
- Remove intake tube and airbox
- Remove vacuum lines
- Loosen plenum bolts
- Remove water lines from
throttlebody & idle speed control valve (ISCV)
- Disconnect cold start injector from
the plenum
- Disconnect electrical plug from
ISCV
- Remove Diagnostic connector from
plenum
- Lift plenum clear of intake runners
- Disconnect water temp sensor and
ignition coil
- Loosen wiring harness from valley
of intake manifold
- Remove fuel rails and injectors
(17mm socket for banjo bolts)
- Remove intake runners
If you're using 40mm throttlebodies
you can stop after you remove the plenum but for 45's you'll
have to continue and remove the intake runners to enlarge
the opening where the throttle bodies bolt on so there is no
sudden step. With all the
intake removed and the fuel rails out of the way there doesn't
seem to be much engine left. Something I did notice was how much
crud had accumulated in the vee of the block. This shot shows
why changing the starter motor is such a PITA... that's it
tucked right in the middle of the valley.

Refitting the manifold is easy enough but
be careful with the injectors to be sure that the rubber seals
are seated properly and aren't getting squashed.
Then you can bolt the wiring harness back
in place in the centre and for the waterline that was going
through the throttlebody and ISCV I used some fuel injection
hose through the middle here:

This is the tube for the vacuum lines to
the MAP sensor which is 10mm OD aluminium with pneumatic
connectors from
Festo
which are also used in the throttlebodies. The line to the MAP
sensor & fuel pressure regulator is in the middle underneath.

When bolting on the throttlebodies I had to
take extra care to ensure the adjoining shafts were totally
parallel - if they met at the slightest angle they would bind
and not fully close. I found it easiest to tighten the joiner
before tightening the bolts to the manifold to ensure
everything's square (indicated below).

Here's the OEM TPS which I adapted to fit.

...and all bolted onto the manifold

I made gaskets from 1mm gasket paper which
sit on the throttlebodies and the top of the throttle cable
bracket lines up with the top of the gaskets. When the plate is
bolted down, a countersunk hex bolt screws into the cable
bracket to brace it.

The plate bolts to the throttlebodies with
countersunk hex bolts then the trumpets fit over the top.
I ordered a custom air filter from
UniFilter
which fits over the lot until I get around to having a cold air
intake system made with remote air filters behind the headlights.

In the above shot you can just see the oil
catch can in the right side of the shot which just has a mini
air filter on it for now, but this will be plumbed into a source
of vacuum soon. This really does need vacuum to suck the blow-by
and other contaminants out of the crankcase to stop it fouling
the oil, not to mention the emissions concerns.
I'm using a vacuum pump to provide vacuum
for the brake booster and I fitted this along with a vacuum tank
from a Saab in front of the driver side front wheel. I used the
existing wiring for the old air suspension compressor to power
it.

The white object is the vac tank and the
pump is next to the chassis rail - the photo was taken from the
wheel arch looking forward. Here's
an overview shot with the major items labelled.
 |
1.
Throttle pulley
2. Cruise control/return spring bracket
3. Return spring
4. Throttle stops
5. Joiners |
6.
Vacuum lines
7. Throttle Position Sensor
8. Diagnostics port
9. Fuel Pressure Regulator |
Issues
Sealing
The main problem I faced from the beginning was getting a good
seal when the butterflies were closed. The stock cams only have
a small overlap so the vacuum at idle is very strong and 8 small
air leaks from each throttle body quickly turn into 1 large air
leak resulting in a high idle speed around 1500rpm.
I sent the throttlebodies to EFI Hardware
to have new butterflies machined up and they did a good job but
the air was also leaking around the throttle shafts as the holes
in the casting were too large. I tried various ways to get them
to seal better but what finally worked was 4 coats of Loctite
Moly Dry Film Lubricant spray inside the bore and around the
butterflies. An hour after each coat I cracked open the
butterflies, closed them and did another coat.

This brought the idle speed from 1500rpm+
down to 600rpm cold and 800rpm warm which is perfect. The seal
around the butterflies is airtight so it's actually idling on
the air leaks around the throttle shafts. I may re-employ the
Idle Speed Control Valve so the ECU can raise the idle speed
for cold starts to avoid stalling.
Sticking Butterflies
Getting the butterflies to fully close when gradually leaning on
and off the throttle was also a problem. The main cause of this
was that the shafts weren't exactly in line and met at a very
slight angle. With the joiner tightened up it limited the free
rotation of the shafts so I had to very carefully check and
double check the alignment as I tightened the bolts connecting
the throttle bodies to the manifold.
With the throttles moving freely I still
needed a relatively strong return spring so when the butterflies
are closed slowly they wouldn't have any friction problems. I
needed quite a long spring so it would provide a fairly constant
force over about 10cm of movement.
Vacuum
The first thing I noticed when I first started the car
(apart from the high idle) was how low the vacuum appeared to
be. With the stock intake it was around 25-27 inHg at idle but
had dropped to about 8 with the ITB's which meant I'd lost about
2/3 of my resolution in the fuel map. What I didn't know was
that the vacuum signal seen by the MAP sensor is inherently
lower with an ITB setup but even 8 inHg was too low. This was
because my first design used a collection tank for all the
vacuum lines then everything that needed vacuum fed into that.
The problem there was the PCV and charcoal canister both let
air/vapour into the tank which lowered the vac signal.
After separating the MAP sensor and Fuel
Pressure Regulator to their own vacuum lines the vacuum at idle
went up to about 15 inHg which was much better so I asked for a
custom firmware for the MAP-ECU which went from 15inches to 0 so
I could have the full resolution of the table. This worked much
better until I was cruising on the open road and it would
hesitate when opening the throttle from closed. After checking
on the laptop it was evident that the vacuum when cruising went
as high as 21 inHg so the flat spot was a result of the MAP-ECU
waiting for the vacuum to go from 21 to 15 before it would
register. In the end I settled on
a firmware which goes from 23 inches to 0 which covers the full
range but still gives small increments for fine tuning, but had
I known what to expect it would have saved a lot of time.
Tuning
I did most of the fuel tuning myself as I
have a wideband AFR meter which I covered in the MAP-ECU section
here but because the
shape of the fuel table had changed it took some time. Something
else which hindered my efforts was the stock ECU when running in
closed loop so I had to disconnect the oxygen sensors in the
extractors to stop it interfering. Before I did that I couldn't
work out why I was getting an AFR of about 20:1 even though I
was adding heaps of fuel. It seems that when the ECU saw it was
far too rich, it compensated too much and pulled out way too
much fuel. Once I started removing fuel, it started to register
as rich once it got back into a range the ECU deemed
acceptable.... not exactly intuitive.
*UPDATE* - I've recently found out why the
wideband was seeing a lean mixture even though it was too rich.
When it gets overly rich it will misfire so when this occurs in
a cylinder it is mainly clean air flowing out of the exhaust
port - this sends the reading way off the lean end of the scale.
When the idle was high it was running OK,
but not as well as it should and sometimes it felt like the ECU
was cutting fuel when the car was stationary in an attempt to
bring the idle down as the exhaust would pop a bit as though it
were too lean, the revs would drop, then they'd come back up and
on it would go. I took it to the dyno but they couldn't tune it
as the ECU was pulling timing and adding fuel all over the
place. After I sorted out the
idling problem and the idle came down to the normal range of
600-800rpm it instantly felt much smoother and more willing to
rev. I took it back to
Unique Autosports for another run on the dyno and it ran
smoothly and without any issues which allowed Ben to finish
tuning the fuel map. He was initially skeptical that it'd be any
different to the week before when it was being a pig, but even
though it was his day off he gave it a go and we were both
pleasantly surprised to see it reel off 178kw at the wheels by
the time he was done. John at UAS was who put me onto the moly
spray to help seal the butterflies so they've been extremely
helpful.

While I'm happy with the peak power, what
I've really noticed is the mid-range punch that it didn't have
before. When changing from 2nd to 3rd at WOT it felt like it had
to climb up the torque curve again as it lacked that real shove
in the back. Now, however it feels like it has gobs of torque
from about 2000rpm onwards. There
is a bit of a flat spot at around 3700 on the graph but looking
back at an old dyno sheet when it had a totally stock intake
that was always there so it's probably a characteristic of the
engine but it's not noticeable on the road.
If you compare the output of stock V8
Soarer which is about 125-130rwkw with the graph above, you can
see that I get the same power at about 4000rpm... not bad! Now
we just need to extend that power curve up to about 6500 or
7000rpm which a nice set of custom cams will do. Well, that'll
be in a few months as I just want to enjoy what I have for now
:-) |